Hart - Made some smart saves, particularly in the first half. 7

Zabaleta - Some promising forays into Everton territory but a little reckless in the challenge. 7

Ball - Steady enough performance. Lack of support on the left didn't help. 6

Dunne - Strong in the challenge as you'd expect. Needlessly gave away the corner for the goal. 6

Richards - A lack of decisiveness at times put us in danger. 5

Kompany - Another solid performance and tried to generate momentum. 7

Wright-Phillips - Was often the creative outlet other players turned to. 7

Ireland - Fading a little and in need of being rested. 6

Elano - Some nice passes but the deeper role is stifling his talents. 6

Robinho - Not fully fit and struggled to really impose himself. 6

Benjani - A willing runner but failed to create a presence. 5

Substitutes:

Jo - A surprise introduction but failed to offer much for the team or help his confidence. 5

Vassell - Little time for any real impact. 6